CONCORDANCE: PERSPECTIVES OF HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS IN
MALAYSIA
Mohd.
Ali S, Anderson C, and Bissell P
Centre for Pharmacy, Health and Society,
School of Pharmacy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD
paxsm2@nottingham.ac.uk
Introduction
Malaysia is a multi-ethnic country, with a population of 25 million1.
Within Malaysia, the increasing prevalence of diabetes has lead to much concern1
and it is estimated that 2 million people are diabetic2. Instituting
preventive measures and promoting greater awareness of self-care among people
with diabetes is vital. Concordant consultations between patients and their
health care professionals may help to achieve effective self-management and
improve outcomes 3. The aim of this qualitative study was to explore
health professionals’ perspectives on their relationships with patients with
diabetes.
Method
Interviews were conducted in June 2003, with 13 Health Care Professionals (9
doctors, 3 pharmacists and 1 diabetic nurse educator), comprising 10 Malays (2
males and 8 females), 3 Chinese (3 females) at an Endocrinology Unit at a
teaching hospital in Malaysia. Interviews were audio taped and transcribed. The
transcripts were coded, then analysed for emerging themes and trends and the
NVivo 2.0 software was used for data management.
Result
The dominant and most consistent themes that emerged from interviews with
the health care professionals were issues around time, patients’ knowledge of
diabetes, education levels, patients’ orientation towards participation in the
consultation, motivational factors, health care system and management issues
that needed to be addressed in order to sustain concordant relationships. All
the doctors interviewed, raised the issue of time constraints as a barrier to
achieving concordant consultations. Some doctors agreed that to have a
concordant relationship, patients’ education level such as tertiary education
and knowledge of diabetes (where they know the rational of treatment given by
the doctors) would help them to participate in the treatment decision-making and
would enhance concordance. However, some health care professionals believed that
patients who were motivated to seek information about diabetes could help
towards improving their disease better. Some health care professionals cited
patients’ beliefs about treatment such as a belief that disease was a result
of fate, alongside rituals and festivities which hindered concordant
relationship with their patients since they showed less interest in their
disease. Besides these factors, issues of health system (e.g. where patients did
not see the same doctor) and management (e.g. lacked of co-ordination in
diabetic education) were also raised as areas to be addressed to enhance
concordance and ultimately improve diabetic care among patients.
Conclusion
Consistent themes emerged from the 13 interviews. There are clearly a number
of socio-cultural issues, time, motivation, health and management system which
need to be addressed in order for the health care professionals to have a
concordant relationship with their patients. They agreed that if these issues
were addressed, these might have a significant impact on diabetic
self-management and would enhance concordance.
References
- Ismail, IS; Nazaimoon, W; Mohamad, W; Letchuman, R; Singaraveloo, M; Hew,
FL; Shuguna, C; and Khalid, BAK. (2001). Ethnicity and glycaemic control are
major determinants of diabetic dyslipidaemia in Malaysia. Diabetic Medicine,
Vol.18, 501-508.
- Zaini, A. (2000). Where is Malaysia in the midst of the Asian epidemic of
diabetes mellitus? Diabetes Research and Clinical Practice 50 Suppl.
2 S23-S28).
- Hampson, S.E., and McKay H.G and Glasgow, R.E. (1996). Patients-physician
interactions in diabetes management: Consistencies and variation in the
structure and content of two consultations. Patient education and
Counselling Vol. 29(1): 49-58.
Presented at the HSRPP Conference 2005, Reading
|