|
FACTORS INFLUENCING THE CHOICE BETWEEN SELF-CARE AND HEALTH PROFESSIONAL
ADVICE IN MINOR ILLNESS: A DISCRETE CHOICE EXPERIMENT
Porteous T, Bond C, Hannaford P, Ryan M, Wyke, S. (t.porteous@abdn.ac.uk)
Department of General Practice and Primary Care, University of Aberdeen
AB25 2AY
Introduction
Recent years have seen an increasing emphasis from the UK Government
on self-care at all levels of health care, from self-management of chronic
diseases to self-treatment of minor illnesses. A recent survey in England
found that while the majority of respondents said that they already practised
self-care for minor illness, barriers to self-care still existed . It
is believed that many people continue to consult their GP for conditions
that could be safely self-managed. It has been proposed that improvements
in self-care could be achieved through modifying access to health services
and health information, thus improving uptake and effectiveness of self-care
.
Discrete choice experiments (DCEs) have been developed and adapted from
the field of marketing to elicit preferences in health care. A specially
designed questionnaire presents individuals with choices involving scenarios
described in terms of attributes and associated levels. Respondents are
asked to choose their preferred option from a number of scenarios combining
these attributes at different levels. Analysis yields information on the
relative importance of these attributes and measures how respondents trade
between them.
Aims
To determine the relative importance of some of the factors
(attributes) associated with decision-making processes in the management
of minor illness, and if/how people trade between these factors
.
Design
Qualitative interviews to identify factors influencing
decision-making in minor illness, and a discrete choice experiment to
determine their relative importance.
Methods
Semi-structured qualitative interviews were conducted with 24 subjects
from a random sample of respondents to an earlier population survey based
in Scotland . Amongst the topics explored at interview were participants'
reasons for practising self-care and/or consulting health professionals,
and their opinions on self-care. Content analysis of the interview data
yielded numerous factors that appeared to affect participants' decisions
to either self-care or consult. From this list, factors that could potentially
be influenced through organisation of health services and/or policy were
identified and incorporated into a DCE questionnaire. Respondents were
asked to identify their preferences for managing a given minor illness
scenario (symptoms included headache, fever and aching). This was mailed
to 652 individuals, also respondents to the previous survey3, who had
agreed to participate in further research.
Results
The questionnaire was administered during November 2005. The attributes
identified for inclusion in the DCE were; type of management (consultation
with general practitioner, practice nurse or complementary therapist,
advice from a community pharmacy or NHS24, self-care and do nothing);
time taken to deal with symptoms (including availability of professionals);
and costs associated with treatment. Availability of information was also
identified as an influencing factor but for design reasons, could not
be incorporated into the DCE. This was included as a separate question
elsewhere in the questionnaire.
To date, the response rate to the questionnaire is 53% (n=278). Analysis
of the DCE using the statistical software STATA is ongoing and the results
of the analysis will be presented at the conference.
References
1. Department of Health. February 2005. Public Attitudes to Self-care
Baseline Survey.
2. Rogers A, Entwistle V, Pencheon D. A patient led NHS: managing demand
at the interface between lay and primary care. BMJ 1998;316:1816-1819
3. Porteous T, Bond C, Hannaford P, Sinclair H. How and why are non-prescription
analgesics used in Scotland? Family Practice 2005;22:78-85
Presented at the HSRPP Conference 2006, Bath
|