|
Reliable Measurement of Perceptions of Tuberculosis Patients
Rennie TW*, Bates IP*, Engova D*, Bothamley GH#
*Dept. Practice & Policy, School of Pharmacy, Univ. London, # East
London Tuberculosis Services, Homerton University Hospital
Introduction
A recent increase in tuberculosis (TB) in the UK has been observed
in certain areas and patient groups, such as ethnic groups in London1.
The emergence of resistance to antituberculous drugs and patient non-adherence
rates to this potentially life-threatening disease suggests that conventional
medicine, defined by the biomedical model, has failed to resolve the problem
of TB2. Misconceptions about TB are partly to blame for disease stigma
and may thwart eradication3. Beliefs about illness and medication have
been useful in predicting and preventing non-adherence to medication and
poor treatment outcomes for other diseases4,5. A similar approach could
be applied in TB management. However, this relies on the valid and reliable
measurement of appropriate constructs. This study reports the reliabilities
of scales used to measure perceptions of TB patients.
Method
Adult TB patients receiving treatment were recruited from three out-patient
clinics in Northeast London. A questionnaire was completed including 1)
six scales from the Revised Illness Perceptions Questionnaire (IPQ-R6),
2) the two scales from the Perceived Utility of Medicines scale (PUM7),
and 3) various socio-cultural and medicines-behaviour indicators. The
questionnaire was completed before or after patients attended clinics.
Data were entered into SPSS® database. Factor analysis and internal
reliability testing were performed.
Results
The questionnaire was completed by 118 patients (65.6% response).
More men (58.3%) than women were recruited and the sample was ethnically
diverse (Asian 47.2%, Black 29.6%, White 20.4%, and Mixed 2.8%) suggesting
good representation.
Initial reliability testing of the six pre-defined scales in the IPQ-R
suggested item discrepancies. Factor analysis was conducted to identify
factor structure. After excluding a number of items due to poor factor
loading, an eight factor solution was found to explain 67.8% variance.
After testing for reliability, a two-item factor was excluded due to poor
internal consistency. A number of items were returned to their original
scales due to acceptable correlation and internal consistency in original
scales. Characteristics of the final seven scales are shown in Table 1.
This included a new 3-item 'Pessimism' scale. Factor analysis was also
used to characterise one item to the two scales of the PUM. Internal reliabilities
were acceptable (Table 1).
| Table 1: IPQ-R and PUM scale characteristics |
| Scale |
Mean
|
Variance
|
S.D.*
|
#
|
| Timeline (IPQ1-4) |
10.18 |
9.638 |
3.104 |
.681 |
| Consequences (IPQ6-11) |
18.69 |
25.291 |
5.029 |
.769 |
| Personal Control (IPQ13-17) |
17.83 |
11.319 |
3.364 |
.637 |
| Cure/Control (IPQ19-23) |
20.27 |
7.258 |
2.694 |
.706 |
| Coherence (IPQ24-28) |
16.47 |
15.221 |
3.901 |
.745 |
| Emotional Represetations (IPQ33-38) |
17.85 |
36.358 |
6.030 |
.900 |
| Fatalism (IPQ2,5,19) |
6.22 |
4.800 |
2.191 |
.678 |
| Perceived Harm of Medicines (T1,2,4,6) |
11.42 |
13.524 |
3.678 |
7.31 |
| Perceived Harm of Medicines (T3,5,7) |
11.85 |
4.145 |
2.036 |
6.56 |
| *S.D.=Standard deviation; # =Cronbach's alpha coefficient |
Conclusion
Some scales from the IPQ-R were adjusted according to the variance
of the sample collected. Both IPQ-R and PUM scales demonstrated acceptable
reliabilities for this diverse patient sample. These scales can now be
used in further analysis investigating relationships between perceptions
and 1) demographic/clinical variables, and 2) adherence
References
1. Blenkinsopp A, Bond C. Over-the-counter medication. London: BMA publication
unit, 2005. pp17.
2. Flint L, Rivers P. Evaluation of the Pharmacy First Service.
http://www.pharmj.com/pdf/extra/pj_20030809_p167derby.pdf (accessed 7
May, 2004).
3. Schafheutle E, Noyce P, Sheehy C et al. Direct supply of medicines
in Scotland : Evaluation of a pilot scheme. http://www.scotland.gov.uk/cru/resfinds/hcc29.pdf
(accessed 7 May, 2004).
4. Kemper N. Minor ailments scheme now involves over a third of Sheffield's
pharmacist. Prescribing & Medicines Management 2004: PM2.
5. Bwrdd Lechyd Lleol Local Health Board. Castell-nedd Port Talbot Neath
Port Talbot. A community pharmacy service to treat minor ailments. http://www.rpsgb.org.uk/wales/pdfs/akent.pdf
(accessed 28 November, 2005).
Presented at the HSRPP Conference 2006, Bath
|