|
THE EFFECT OF COMMUNICATION SKILLS TRAINING ON CONSULTATIONS FOR NON-PRESCRIPTION
MEDICINES
Watson MC, Inch J, Cleland J, Francis J, Bond CM.
Dept. General Practice and Primary Care, University of Aberdeen, Westburn
Road, Aberdeen AB252AY, Scotland. (m.c.watson@abdn.ac.uk)
Background
British government policy has led to an increasing number of medicines
being reclassified from Prescription Only Medicines to non-prescription
medicines. This has resulted in a wider range of medicines being available
for sale to the general public in community pharmacies. Previous research1
indicates that the sale of non-prescription medicines by medicine counter
assistants (MCAs) is not always appropriate and does not always comply
with Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain (RSPGB) guidelines2
for the safe and effective supply of medicines to patients. Sub-optimal
communication between MCAs and customers has been identified as a major
cause of the inappropriate supply of these medicines3. The hypothesis
tested by this study is that communication skills training for MCAs will
improve their practise, in terms of the supply of NPMs.
Objective
This feasibility study was conducted to develop, deliver and evaluate
a communication skills training intervention, aimed at improving information
exchange between MCAs and customers during consultations for non-prescription
medicines.
Method
MCAs were recruited from community pharmacies in Grampian, Scotland
and randomised (using a 2:1 ratio) to either the intervention or control.
Up to two MCAs from each pharmacy could participate. The intervention
group was invited to attend two communication skills training events.
A training package was developed using cognitive behavioural therapy and
a mixture of techniques including: didactic sessions; group discussion
and role-play (both demonstrated and individual). The effect of the training
was assessed using covert, simulated patient visits. Each MCA was scheduled
to receive four covert visits (two at baseline, then one after each of
the training sessions). The simulated patients wore concealed microphones
to record the consultations. Following each visit, the simulated patient
also completed a data collection form. The outcome measures that were
used to assess the effect of training included: open questions as a proportion
of total questions asked; the total number of questions asked; the use
of individual WWHAM questions, as well as a Total WWHAM Score; and, compliance
with the RPSGB guidelines for the supply of pharmacy medicines.
Results
In total, 93 (89.4%) of the 104 scheduled simulated patient visits
were completed. Few consultations involved open questions at any time
point and for either group. Preliminary analysis of the results shows
that the median total number of questions asked increased at each time
point in the intervention group, and remained constant then decreased
for the control group. The effect of training appears to have been more
pronounced for consultations involving advice requests compared with direct
product requests.
Implications for practice
The preliminary results are encouraging as they suggest a general trend
within the intervention group towards enhanced communication skills and
hence an improvement in information exchange between MCAs and patients.
If the overall results of the study confirm this trend, then a large scale
randomised controlled study will be conducted of the effectiveness and
cost-effectiveness of this intervention. As the number of reclassified
medicines increases, MCAs have greater responsibility in ensuring their
safe and effective supply. Communication skills training may help them
to achieve this goal.
References
1. Watson MC, Bond CM, Grimshaw JM, Mollison J, Ludbrook
A, Walker A. Educational Strategies To Promote Evidence-Based Community
Pharmacy Practice: A Cluster Randomised Controlled Trial (RCT). Family
Practice 2002;19:529-36.
2. Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain. Medicines, Ethics and
Practice. London: RPSGB; 2005. Report No.: 29.
3. Watson MC, Bond CM. The evidence based supply of non-prescription medicines:
barriers and beliefs. IJPP 2004;12(June):65-72.
Presented at the HSRPP Conference 2006, Bath
|